Influence of changing temperature on growth rate and competition between two psychrotolerant Antarctic bacteria: competition and survival in non-steady-state temperature environments

Competition between two psychrotolerant bacteria was examined in glycerol-limited chemostat experiments subjected to non-steady-state conditions of temperature. One bacterium, a Brevibacterium sp. strain designated CR3/1/15, responded rapidly to temperature change, while a second, Hydrogenophaga pseudoflava, designated CR3/2/10, exhibited a lag in growth after a shift-down during a square-wave temperature cycle but not after a shift-up. The effects on competition and survival by these bacteria of both sine-wave and square-wave temperature changes between 2 and 16 degrees C over a 24-h cycle time were examined, as well as square-wave cycles over 12 and 96 h. The changing proportion of each bacterium in the chemostat was determined by plate counting at regular intervals. Under a sine-wave temperature cycle H. psedoflava outcompeted the Brevibacterium sp., but under square-wave temperature cycles the two bacteria coexisted because the lag by H. pseudoflava after the temperature shift-down favored the faster-responding Brevibacterium sp. The two bacteria thus exhibited different survival strategies, with H. pseudoflava adapted to effective competition under steady-state conditions and the Brevibacterium sp. adapted to rapid adaptation and survival in a changing environment. The degree of perturbation of the bacteria, expressed as a temperature challenge index (delta temp/delta time), was greater under a square-wave temperature cycle than under a sine-wave cycle of equivalent amplitude and frequency, and higher-temperature challenge favored the Brevibacterium sp. A computer model was developed to examine competition between the bacteria in transient environments. The frequency of the temperature cycle influenced competition, as with a longer cycle (96 h) the significance of the lag by H. pseudoflava decreased compared with that of a 24-h cycle, and H. pseudoflava predominated in a mixed culture with a 96-h cycle. The shift-down lag by H. pseudoflava, during which it adapted to low temperature, disadvantaged it in a changing temperature environment, but at a short cycle time (12 h) this disadvantage was countered by the incomplete loss of low-temperature adaptation between cycles and thus the carryover of some low-temperature adaptation. Also, it was demonstrated that, as well as consideration of the effect of temperature changes on inducing lags in growth, the loss of adaptation to low temperature between cycles had to be taken into account in the computer model if it was to reproduce the trends in the experimental data.


Publication status:
Authors: Rutter, M., Nedwell, D.B.

1 June, 1994
Applied and Environmental Microbiology / 60